In May, the unemployment rate didn’t fall to 13.3% like almost everyone believes it did.
I’ve never seen anything like what happened on Friday when May’s unemployment rate was expected to rise to almost 20%. That would top April’s tragic 14.7% rate. But at 8:30 a.m. EDT, the Bureau of Labor Statistics announced the rate fell to 13.3%.
Pandemonium followed and traders started buying almost everything in the stock market. By the end of the day, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was up more than 3%.
But analysts like me who read BLS’s full press release noted something strange on the sixth page of the 42-page report. There, they learned the unemployment rate was really 16.3%.
Government Reports Bad Unemployment Data
That’s actually what the report says. Part of the section called “Coronavirus (COVID-19) Impact on May 2020 Establishment and Household Survey Data” is show below. The important news is highlighted.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics
BLS economists noticed there was a mistake in data collection. They didn’t correct the mistake. Instead. “to maintain data integrity, no ad hoc actions are taken…”
This is stunning. In May, the unemployment rate didn’t fall to 13.3% like almost everyone believes it did.
There’s no obvious reason to report bad data. Unemployment was expected to be at least 19.5% and rose to just 16.3%. That still would have been good news and stocks almost certainly would have gone up.
But because of a mistake and what seems like a flawed decision by the BLS, a significantly lower unemployment number was announced.
This is important news for stock market investors to consider.
First, unemployment is not improving. It increased in May as everyone expected. That’s consistent with what we all saw, which was an economy that was shut down.
Second, Friday’s rally was based on a mistake. Traders were buying because, as the White House noted, “This is better than a V. This is a rocket ship.”
However, it’s not a rocket ship or a V. It’s still looking for a bottom.
Finally, when the facts become widely known, traders may react as if the news was purposely misleading. This could undermine confidence in government numbers and add to uncertainty in the stock market.
This will be an important story for anyone who lacks full faith and confidence in the government. It will make all analysts and traders skeptical of news releases for some time.
Most importantly, it tells us to expect a sharp pullback as traders realize how bad unemployment is and how unlikely the V-shaped recovery is when policymakers aren’t using accurate data to guide them.
I’ve never seen a time when government data was deliberately misleading like this. Without a precedent, we should assume the worst and prepare for a reaction equal to or greater than Friday’s initial reaction.
A note from Michael Carr: As traders react violently to news, now is an excellent time to consider trading with strategies that take short-term positions and manage risks. I’ll be sharing details about a strategy built on those principles tomorrow. This strategy holds positions an average of two days and has delivered a gain of more than 76% in the first five months of the year in an account I trade for a local animal rescue. If you’d like to learn more, click here.
• Michael Carr is a Chartered Market Technician for Banyan Hill Publishing and the Editor of One Trade, Peak Velocity Trader and Precision Profits. He teaches technical analysis and quantitative technical analysis at New York Institute of Finance. Mr. Carr also is the former editor of the CMT Association newsletter Technically Speaking.
Follow him on Twitter @MichaelCarrGuru.